The Sin of Silence: When Catholic Leaders Fail to Defend Life

“It is precisely from obedience to God … that the strength and the courage to resist unjust human laws are born.”

― Pope St. John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae, no. 73

A little over three weeks ago, on October 20, the Princely House of Liechtenstein announced that Hereditary Prince Alois would refuse to sign a bill legalizing abortion through the first twelve weeks of pregnancy.

The bill grew out of a citizens’ initiative that gathered 4,970 signatures, close to a quarter of the principality’s eligible voters. On September 2, the 25-member Landtag approved it by 13 votes to 12. By the same, narrow one-vote margin, the deputies declined to put the question to a referendum.

The explanation from the prince’s office for his decision to veto the bill was brief. “Following careful consideration,” the statement said, “he remains convinced that the proposed reform is not compatible with ensuring adequate protection of unborn life as a fundamental legal value.”

It is the first time Prince Alois has used his veto in more than twenty years as regent for his father, Prince Hans-Adam II. Abortion therefore remains a crime in Liechtenstein, except in cases of rape or grave danger to the mother’s life or health.

I wrote about Liechtenstein this summer, when the prince first said he would not sign any legislation legalizing abortion. In that column I recounted how voters rejected legal abortion in 2011, and how, a year later, more than three-quarters of them voted to keep the prince’s veto. In other words, the people resoundingly affirmed the Prince’s power to do precisely what he has just done.

This week I would like to consider what the prince’s decision has to teach the rest of us, and in particular those Catholics who hold public office.

The Prince’s Veto: Surreal?

Abortion campaigners were predictably outraged. Tatjana As’Ad, who led the initiative, told The Guardian that the veto was “surreal.” The committee behind the initiative complained that a single man had overruled both a quarter of the country’s voters and its parliament.

In other words, The Guardian is saying, the prince is a relic: a man in a castle, standing athwart the march of progress.

There is another way to read the story, however. Prince Alois has never hidden where he stands. He said in 2011 what he would do, and he said it again in June. In an interview with the Liechtensteiner Vaterland, he explained that a law permitting abortion on request means the state is walking away from its duty to protect preborn life. And he explained why he was announcing his decision ahead of time: “a head of state should take a clear stand and also bear responsibility.”

If anything in this story deserves to be called surreal, it is how seldom one hears a public official talk this way. Faced with a contested moral question, most politicians would far rather take no stand at all, and leave the responsibility with somebody else, hiding beneath the fig leaf of a misguided understanding of democracy and “the will of the people.”

Kings, Princes, and a Grand Duke Defend the Preborn

Prince Alois is not the first European monarch to refuse to put his name to such a law.

In 1990, King Baudouin of Belgium refused to sign his country’s new abortion law. In a letter to Prime Minister Wilfried Martens, he wrote that the bill raised in him “a grave problem of conscience,” and he asked whether freedom of conscience applied to everyone except the king. The government got around him by declaring him temporarily unable to reign and enacting the law in his absence.

Thirty-four years later, Pope Francis prayed at King Baudouin’s tomb and praised him for choosing to “leave his place as king in order not to sign a murderous law.” At the end of Mass in Brussels, the Holy Father announced that he would open Baudouin’s cause for beatification. Speaking to reporters on the flight home, he praised King Baudouin’s moral courage. “You need a politician who wears pants to do this,” he said, using a Spanish expression.

In 2008, King Baudouin’s nephew, Grand Duke Henri of Luxembourg, refused to sign a law legalizing euthanasia. Parliament responded by amending the constitution to strip him of his power to approve laws, and the euthanasia law took effect the following year without his signature.

And a year ago this month, Prince Albert II of Monaco refused to sign a bill legalizing abortion through twelve weeks, even though Monaco’s National Council had passed it by 19 votes to 2. He cited “the place that the Catholic religion holds in our country.”

Majority Opinions Cannot Override Moral Law

Each of these men was accused, as Prince Alois is now, of imposing his private religious convictions on a democratic majority. However, each understood that a Catholic does not stop being a Catholic simply because he is a monarch with political power, and that a law permitting the killing of the innocent does not become just because a parliament voted for it.

As Pope St. John Paul II reminded us in Evangelium Vitae, “the value of democracy stands or falls with the values which it embodies and promotes” (no. 70).

He continued:

Of course, values such as the dignity of every human person, respect for inviolable and inalienable human rights, and the adoption of the ‘common good’ as the end and criterion regulating political life are certainly fundamental and not to be ignored.

In answer to those who would point at the values of democracy and the will of the people, the Holy Father pointed us to more fundamental values:

The basis of these [fundamental] values cannot be provisional and changeable ‘majority’ opinions, but only the acknowledgment of an objective moral law which, as the ‘natural law’ written in the human heart, is the obligatory point of reference for civil law itself.

In other words, any democratically approved law that violates a fundamental truth about the dignity of the human person is inherently invalid, as it does not cohere with the deepest truths of reality.

We Cannot Have Two Parallel Lives

Of course, most Catholics in public life are not monarchs. They are legislators, senators, judges, and other officials who answer to voters, and who may be voted out of office for an unpopular stand. But the principle that guided King Baudouin and Prince Alois applies to them just the same.

The Second Vatican Council warned against keeping one’s faith in one compartment and one’s public duties in another. “This split between the faith which many profess and their daily lives,” the Council Fathers wrote, “deserves to be counted among the more serious errors of our age” (Gaudium et Spes, no. 43).

In its 2002 Doctrinal Note on the participation of Catholics in political life, the then-called Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith quoted Pope St. John Paul II’s apostolic exhortation Christifideles Laici:

There cannot be two parallel lives in their existence: on the one hand, the so-called ‘spiritual life’, with its values and demands; and on the other, the so-called ‘secular’ life, that is, life in a family, at work, in social responsibilities, in the responsibilities of public life and in culture.

Unfortunately, the divided life is far too common among Catholic politicians. Over the years I have written often in this column about Joe Biden and Nancy Pelosi, both self-described “devout” Catholics who championed legal abortion. Their defense of their actions is a familiar one: they are “personally” opposed to abortion but cannot impose their beliefs on others. Even if this were true, of course, it is curious just how hard-pressed one would be to find any evidence of their “personal” opposition to abortion, given that they never seem to feel inclined to express that opposition, even outside of any official political act. Understandably, one wonders if they aren’t just playing verbal games.

The Church’s teaching leaves no room for this formula. “In the case of an intrinsically unjust law, such as a law permitting abortion or euthanasia,” wrote Pope St. John Paul II, “it is therefore never licit to obey it, or to ‘take part in a propaganda campaign in favor of such a law, or vote for it’” (Evangelium Vitae, no. 73). The Doctrinal Note is equally clear: “a well-formed Christian conscience does not permit one to vote for a political program or an individual law which contradicts the fundamental contents of faith and morals.”

It would have been the easiest thing in the world for Prince Alois to fall back on the usual dodge. “I’m personally against abortion,” he might have said, “but who am I to overrule the people’s elected representatives?” However, he knew that, had he signed, it would have been his law, and every child who died under it would have been on his conscience. And he stood firm.

The Sins of Omission: “What I Have Failed to Do”

At the beginning of Mass, in the Confiteor, we confess that we have sinned “in what I have done and in what I have failed to do.” Often, we say it without thinking about what we are saying. However, especially for Catholic legislators, the words should strike a healthy fear in their hearts. The culture of death advances through sins of omission even more than it does through sins of commission.

The sins of commission are the obvious ones. The legislator who actively supports and votes for an abortion law commits a grave injustice against the preborn. Remember that in Liechtenstein the bill squeaked through by one vote. If just one deputy had found the backbone to vote no, the bill would have died on the floor, and the prince would never have had to step in.

So, what about sins of omission? Pope St. John Paul II places responsibility for abortion on “the legislators who have promoted and approved abortion laws.” But he goes further. “A general and no less serious responsibility,” he writes, “lies with those who have encouraged the spread of an attitude of sexual permissiveness and a lack of esteem for motherhood, and with those who should have ensured – but did not – effective family and social policies in support of families” (Evangelium Vitae, no. 59).

Should have, but did not. How many Catholic officials have quietly abstained on a key vote regarding the dignity of human life, or didn’t bother personally speaking up against it with courage and conviction? How many Catholic voters have never once asked a candidate where they stand on the right to life, instead focusing on lesser issues such as the economy?

Many supposedly “Catholic” politicians justify their moral cowardice under the soothing and popular idea of “tolerance.” Pope St. John Paul II observed that many people consider moral relativism “an essential condition of democracy, inasmuch as it alone is held to guarantee tolerance,” while objective moral norms are thought to “lead to authoritarianism and intolerance” (Evangelium Vitae, no. 70). And so, the Catholic politician who keeps his faith to himself is praised for his open-mindedness, while the one who acts on it is denounced as a theocrat.

In countries such as Kenya (pictured), HLI affiliates educate and engage lawmakers to promote laws that uphold human life and the family. In 2022, HLI Malawi helped mobilize Catholic parliamentarians against a proposed abortion bill. One lawmaker publicly declared that Catholic MPs would boycott proceedings if the bill were introduced. Parliament adjourned without advancing the bill, a significant victory for preborn children in Malawi.

Closely related is indifference. Liechtenstein’s campaigners argued that the veto will not stop abortions, since women will keep traveling to Switzerland or Austria. Perhaps so. But by the same logic, a nation should legalize any crime its citizens can commit across the border. The reality is that laws also teach. A nation that withdraws legal protection from the preborn child tells its citizens that the child’s life is a private matter, of no concern to the community. This, in turn, encourages couples to view it as “no big deal” to travel to a nearby state to have their preborn child killed. That is the message Prince Alois refused to put his name to.

Catholics Need the Courage of the Biblical Midwives

In the passage of Evangelium Vitae that I quoted at the beginning of this column, Pope St. John Paul II recalls the story of the Hebrew midwives in Egypt. When Pharaoh ordered the killing of every newborn Hebrew boy, the midwives refused. “They did not do as the king of Egypt commanded them, but let the male children live” (Ex 1:17). And the reason, the Holy Father notes, was simple: “the midwives feared God.”

There is a certain irony here. In Exodus, it was the king who ordered the killing and the midwives who refused. In Liechtenstein, the roles were reversed: the parliament voted to legalize abortion, and it was the prince who said no.

Either way, the source of that courage is the same, and it is available to every one of us, whether we are legislators who must vote against an abortion bill (or euthanasia bill) at the cost of our seats, or ordinary voters who refuse to support a candidate who would make killing legal. None of us needs a crown. We need only the fear of God, and the willingness to bear responsibility for what we do and what we fail to do.

The culture of death advances wherever Catholics agree to keep their faith to themselves. If we hope to build a civilization of love in its place, we will need many more Catholics, in every walk of life, who are prepared to do what Prince Alois did, and say that they cannot, in conscience, sign.

Human Life International

As president of Human Life International, Fr. Boquet is a leading expert on the international pro-life and family movement, having journeyed to nearly 90 countries on pro-life missions over the last decade. Father Boquet works with pro-life and family leaders in 116 counties that partner with HLI to proclaim and advance the Gospel of Life. Read his full bio here.

Did you find this useful?

Leave a Comment